A Comparative Analysis of the Legal System on the Performance of Islamic Banks: A Study in the United Kingdom, Malaysia and Indonesia

Roqiyul Ma’arif Syam; Mabruri Andatu; Abdul Muiz Abdul Wadud

doi:10.24235/jm.v10i1.20924

A Comparative Analysis of the Legal System on the Performance of Islamic Banks: A Study in the United Kingdom, Malaysia and Indonesia

Roqiyul Ma’arif Syam^(1*), Mabruri Andatu⁽²⁾, Abdul Muiz Abdul Wadud⁽³⁾,

(1) Kent Law School, University of Kent, Canterbury, United Kingdom
(2) Sekolah Tinggi Ilmu Syariah Al Wafa Bogor
(3) International Islamic University of Malaysia
(*) Corresponding Author

Abstract

This research is motivated by the issue of the influence of the legal system on the performance of Islamic banks in three countries with different legal and social backgrounds, namely the United Kingdom (UK), Malaysia and Indonesia. A qualitative-comparative approach is used by focusing on the substantive and procedural legal system aspects that affect the operation of Islamic banks, as well as on performance indicators such as financial stability, operational efficiency, and the level of public trust. The results show that Malaysia has the most supportive legal system for the development of Islamic banks through its dual banking system framework, formal recognition of sharia principles, and integrated regulatory and supervisory institutions. While Indonesia has made progress in the regulatory aspect, it still faces challenges in harmonization between national law and sharia principles, as well as supervisory effectiveness. On the other hand, the UK, despite having a stable legal system, has not provided a sufficient legal basis to support the full operation of Islamic banks, as its regulatory approach is religion-neutral. This research also emphasizes the importance of legal culture and socio-religious context in supporting the performance of the Islamic finance industry. The practical implications of this research include the need for regulatory harmonization, institutional capacity building, and the establishment of international sharia law standards. Thus, strengthening the legal system that is responsive to sharia principles is a strategic key in strengthening the competitiveness of Islamic banks globally.

Keywords: Legal system; United Kingdom; Indonesia; Malaysia; Islamic Bank.

Full Text:

PDF

References

Abbas, K., & Hafeez, M. (2021). Wıll Artıfıcıal Intellıgence Rejuvenate Islamıc Fınance? A Versıon of World Academıa. Hitit Theology Journal, 20(3), 311–324. https://doi.org/10.14395/hid.931401

Abdillah, K., & Susilawati, Y. (2020). Sejarah Kodifikasi Hukum Ekonomi Syariah di Indonesia. Al-Huquq: Journal of Indonesian Islamic Economic Law, 2(1), 114. https://doi.org/10.19105/alhuquq.v2i1.3073

Abdul, A. R., Mandiri, D. P., Astuti, W., & Arkoyah, S. (2022). Tantangan perkembangan perbankan syariah di Indonesia. Jurnal Tabarru’: Islamic Banking and Finance, 5(2), 352–365.

Abdul Rahim, M., Shaharuddin, N. S., & Mohd Suki, N. (2024). Shariah governance disclosure and its effect on Islamic banks’ financial performance: evidence from Malaysia and GCC countries. Journal of Islamic Accounting and Business Research, 15(4), 619–642.

Adawiyah, R. (2022). Analisis Sistem Sharia Compliance pada Pengaturan Perbankan Syariah di Indonesia, Malaysia dan The United Kingdom. Universitas Islam Negeri Kiai Haji Achmad Siddiq Jember.

Aditya, R., & Lestari, B. C. (2025). Sinergi Pengawasan Syariah dan Tantangan Regulasi Fintech dalam Penguatan Tata Kelola Perbankan Syariah di Indonesia. JIMU: Jurnal Ilmiah Multidisipliner, 3(02), 1177–1188.

Agustina, W. (2021). Studi Komparasi Regulasi Lembaga Keuangan Syariah Indonesia Dan Malaysia (Studi: Regulasi Perbankan Syariah Indonesia dan Malaysia). IAIN Syekh Nurjati Cirebon.

Ahmad, M., & Ansary, R. (2017). Fiqhī views on bayʿwa salaf and qarḍ-based Islamic banking deposit accounts in Malaysia. ISRA International Journal of Islamic Finance, 9(1), 106–112. https://doi.org/10.1108/ijif-07-2017-011

Al-Barak, M. J. (2021). Real estate finance in Kuwait–evaluation of the approaches of Islamic and conventional banks. Heriot-Watt University.

Al Ben Ali, L. M. (2020). Regulation and supervision of Kuwait capital markets: a critical analysis of the risk based approach.

Al Ghifari, M. H., & Priyatno, P. D. (2024). The urgency of implementing halal product process assistance: Review of maqashid syariah. Al-Mustashfa: Jurnal Penelitian Hukum Ekonomi Syariah, 9(1), 14–30.

Alafianta, N. F., Aziz, M. A., & Sahputra, J. (2021). A Historical Review of the Development of the Islamic Banking System (An Analytical Study). Al-Iktisab: Journal of Islamic Economic Law, 5(2), 133. https://doi.org/10.21111/al-iktisab.v5i2.6799

Alam, A., Nurrahman, A., & Hamidah, R. A. (2023). Analysis of Judge’s Decision on Akad Murabahah Tort Case in Religious Court. Al-Mustashfa: Jurnal Penelitian Hukum Ekonomi Syariah, 8(2), 149–165.

Aldahmash, A. N. A. (2025). The petition for a liquidation procedure and the administrative liquidation procedure: a comparative analysis study in Saudi and UK insolvency law. International Journal of Law and Management.

Amalia, D., Diana, N., & Ekonomi, F. (2022). Pengaruh Biaya Operasional Terhadap Pendapatan Operasional (BOPO), Capital Adequacy Ratio (CAR), dan Financing to Deposit Ratio (FDR) Terhadap Profitabilitas (ROA) Pada Bank Bukopin Syariah Periode 2013-2020. Jurnal Ilmiah Ekonomi Islam, 8(01), 1095–1102.

Andatu, M., & Arifin, T. (2024). Relevance of Inflation Control According to MA Mannan With Law No. 3 Of 2004. Al-Mustashfa: Jurnal Penelitian Hukum Ekonomi Syariah, 9(2), 268–285.

Aprilia, S. N., Baidhowi, B., & Novita, Y. D. (2025). Peran Regulasi Otoritas Jasa Keuangan Dalam Mencegah Praktik Perbankan Abusive Lending Salsabila Nisa Aprilia, Baidhowi, Yustina Dhian Novita. Media Hukum Indonesia (MHI), 2(6).

Aryani, C. (2021). Reformulasi Sistem Pembentukan Peraturan Perundang-Undangan Melalui Penerapan Omnibus Law. Jurnal USM Law Review, 4(1), 27–48.

Ayub, M., & Khan, M. F. (2021). Evolving Monetary Economics in Islamic Perspective. Journal of Islamic Monetary Economics and Finance, 7(2), 317–340. https://doi.org/10.21098/jimf.v7i2.1372

Baihaki, A., & Monica, S. (2022). Bank Syariah di Inggris. JYRS: Journal of Youth Research and Studies, Vol.3, No., 2808–9758. https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/503491/2015

Bakhtiar, B. (2020). Penyerapan Fatwa Dewan Syariah Nasional Majelis Ulama Indonesia dalam Peraturan Bank Indonesia Pasar Uang Antarbank Berdasarkan Prinsip Syariah. Turast: Jurnal Penelitian Dan Pengabdian, 8(2), 98–119.

Bhand, L. A., Iqbal, T., & Ali, N. (2023). Comparison of Sharia court’s of Pakistan, United Arab Emirates (UAE), Indonesia and Malaysia. Russian Law Journal, 11(2), 593–616.

Bhatti, M. I., & Basov, S. (2022). Incentives, Social Norms, and Business Cycle: an Example of Business Loans Provision By Islamic Banks. Journal of Islamic Monetary Economics and Finance, 8(3), 471–484. https://doi.org/10.21098/jimf.v8i3.1565

Bianda, R. (2024). The Principle of ats-Tsabit bi al-‘Urfi ka ats-Tsabit bi asy-Syar’i in DSN-MUI Fatwa No. 117 on Sharia Fintech. Al-Mustashfa: Jurnal Penelitian Hukum Ekonomi Syariah, 9(2), 205–222.

Brekke, T. (2018). Halal money: Financial inclusion and demand for islamic banking in Norway. Research and Politics, 5(1). https://doi.org/10.1177/2053168018757624

Dahruji, D., & Muslich, A. A. (2022). Pengaruh profitabilitas terhadap financial distress pada bank umum syariah periode 2018–2020. Jurnal Ekonomi Syariah Teori Dan Terapan, 9(3), 388–400.

Daoud, Y., & Kammoun, A. (2024). Banking Regulation and Financial Soundness Nexus in View of the Crisis: An Islamic Banking Perspective. International Journal of Economics and Financial Issues, 14(2), 168–177. https://doi.org/10.32479/ijefi.15760

Darmalaksana, W. (2022). Filsafat dan Politik Hukum Islam Perbankan Syariah. Sentra Publikasi Indonesia.

Dasaklis, T. K., & Malamas, V. (2023). A review of the lightning network’s evolution: Unraveling its present state and the emergence of disruptive digital business models. Journal of Theoretical and Applied Electronic Commerce Research, 18(3), 1338–1364.

Delvina, A. (2021). Strategi pengembangan Marketing Mix dan pengaruhnya terhadap peningkatan nasabah tabungan Ib Maslahah Bank Jabar Banten Syariah di Provinsi Jawa Barat. UIN SUNAN GUNUNG DJATI BANDUNG.

Efendi, J., & Ibrahim, J. (2018). Metode penelitian hukum: normatif dan empiris. Prenada Media.

Espina-Jerez, B., Romera-Álvarez, L., de Dios-Aguado, M., Cunha-Oliveira, A., Siles-Gonzalez, J., & Gómez-Cantarino, S. (2022). Wet Nurse or Milk Bank? Evolution in the Model of Human Lactation: New Challenges for the Islamic Population. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 19(15). https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph19159742

Firdauzi, I., Arifin, A., Alfarisy, M. F., Fauzi, P., Badriah, L. S., Ilma, A. F. N., & Nasution, N. K. U. (2024). How government internal control system supporting regional development goals: Empirical evidence from internal control system in Indonesia. Al-Mustashfa: Jurnal Penelitian Hukum Ekonomi Syariah, 9(1), 94–108.

Gaffar, H., & Al Mamari, S. (2025). From Roman law to Sharia: comparative perspectives on the evolution of quasi-contracts in western and Islamic jurisdictions. Griffith Law Review, 1–26.

Gani, I. M., & Bahari, Z. (2021). Islamic banking’s contribution to the Malaysian real economy. ISRA International Journal of Islamic Finance, 13(1), 6–25.

Ghozali, M., Jubaedah, D., & Yusup, D. K. (2024). Comparative Analysis of Economic Fiqh in Islamic Financial Transactions:‎ A Review of Literature from Various Madhhabs. Al-Mustashfa: Jurnal Penelitian Hukum Ekonomi Syariah, 9(2), 305–320.

Habibunnajar, R. (2020). Problematika Regulasi Pinjam Meminjam Secara Online Berbasis Syariah Di Indonesia (Fintech P2P Lending Syariah). Fakultas Syariah dan Hukum Universitas Islam Negeri Syarif Hidayatullah Jakarta.

Haddad, A., El Ammari, A., & Bouri, A. (2020). Comparative and demonstrative study between the liquidity of Islamic and conventional banks in a financial stability period: Which type of banks is the most liquid? International Journal of Financial Research, 11(1), 252–273. https://doi.org/10.5430/IJFR.V11N1P252

Hafizd, J. Z., Janwari, Y., & Jubaedah, D. (2025). Comparative and Integrative Approach of Conventional and Islamic Economic Theories in Islamic Economic Law Development. Al-Mustashfa: Jurnal Penelitian Hukum Ekonomi Syariah, 10(1), 20–39.

Halida, U. M. (2021). Manajemen Risiko di Era Covid-19 Terhadap Ekonomi di Indonesia. Mabny: Journal of Sharia Management and Business, 1(01), 1–13.

Hamzani, A. I. (2020). Hukum Islam: Dalam Sistem Hukum di Indonesia. Prenada Media.

Haque, M. M. (2021). Ethical issues in profit rate charges in Islamic debt financing with special reference to Islamic personal financing product in Malaysia. ProQuest Dissertations Publishing.

Harahap, N. F., Regar, N. A., Pranata, D. A., Purba, N. N., & Hadiningrum, S. (2024). Kedudukan Hukum Islam Dalam Sistem Hukum Civil Law Dan Common Law Di Indonesia. Indonesian Journal of Islamic Jurisprudence, Economic and Legal Theory, 2(4), 2146–2154.

Harkati, R., Alhabshi, S. M., & Kassim, S. (2020). Influence of economic freedom and its subcomponents on risk-taking behavior: evidence from dual banking system of Malaysia. Review of Behavioral Finance, 12(4), 335–356.

Hartini, S. (2020). Perkembangan Perbankang Syariah Asia Tenggara Berdasarkan Regulasi. Justitia Jurnal Hukum, 4(2).

Hasanah, N., Sayuti, M. N., & Lisnawati, L. (2024). Optimalisasi regulasi perbankan syariah oleh Bank Indonesia dan Otoritas Jasa Keuangan dalam akselerasi transformasi digital. Jurnal Manajemen Terapan Dan Keuangan, 13(03), 709–723.

Hassan, A. (2020). The Challenges and Prospects of Islamic Finance in Australia: A Case Study of Murabaha Contract. Victoria University.

Herijanto, H. (2019). Pertimbangan hakim dalam penyelesaian sengketa akad pembiayaan syariah di Indonesia, Malaysia, dan Inggris.

Hoque, H., & Liu, H. (2023). Impact of bank regulation on risk of Islamic and conventional banks. International Journal of Finance and Economics, 28(1), 1025–1062. https://doi.org/10.1002/ijfe.2462

Ibrahim, M. B., Sari, F. P., Kharisma, L. P. I., Kertati, I., Artawan, P., Sudipa, I. G. I., Simanihuruk, P., Rusmayadi, G., Nursanty, E., & Lolang, E. (2023). Metode Penelitian Berbagai Bidang Keilmuan (Panduan & Referensi). PT. Sonpedia Publishing Indonesia.

Kameliya, S., Febrianti, T., Sutrisno, Z. F. M., & ... (2022). Analisis Komparatif Penerapan Sistem Asuransi Syariah Antara Indonesia dengan Inggris. … National Seminar on …, 2(7), 39–49. http://conference.um.ac.id/index.php/nsafe/article/view/2625

Karumo, A. (2025). The opportunities and challenges of Islamic finance in Europe: what can be learned from the example of the United Kingdom?

Kitamura, H. (2020). Who pioneered Islamic banking in Malaysia? The background of the pioneers of Bank Islam Malaysia Berhad. Contemporary Islam, 14(1), 75–93.

KK, A. S. R., & Maharani, H. N. (2024). Inovasi Dan Pengembangan Produk Keuangan Syariah: Tantangan Dan Prospek Di Era Revolusi Industri 4.0. Jurnal Ilmiah Edunomika, 8(1).

Kumar, M., Poudineh, R., & Shamsuddin, A. (2021). Electricity supply industry reform and design of competitive electricity market in Malaysia (Issue 44). OIES Paper: EL.

Kuswahariani, W., Siregar, H., & Syarifuddin, F. (2020). Analisis Non Performing Financing (NPF) secara umum dan segmen mikro pada tiga bank Syariah Nasional di Indonesia. Jurnal Aplikasi Bisnis Dan Manajemen (JABM), 6(1), 26.

Kuznetsov, A. V., Fituni, L. L., Ryzhkova, E. A., Trofimova, O. E., & Filonik, A. O. (2017). Islamic finance and its specifics in Europe. World Economy and International Relations, 61(12), 52–62. https://doi.org/10.20542/0131-2227-2017-61-12-52-62

Lewis, M. K., & Algaoud, L. M. (2003). Perbankan Syariah: prinsip, pratik, dan prospek. Serambi Ilmu Semesta.

Maulana Syarif Afwa, & Sulistyowati. (2023). Analisis Perkembangan Perbankan Syariah Di Malaysia. Jurnal Ekonomi Bisnis Dan Akuntansi, 3(2), 67–77. https://doi.org/10.55606/jebaku.v3i2.1728

Mumtahaen, I., & Romli, M. (2025). Aspek hukum perbankan syariah dan implementasinya di Indonesia. Al-Urwatul Wutsqo: Jurnal Ilmu Keislaman Dan Pendidikan, 6(1), 209–215.

Mursid, F., Atoillah, M. A., & Nurhisam, L. (2023). Cooperative Member Savings Guarantee As A Form Of Legal Protection In The Maá1¢ Laá¸¤ Ah Perspective. Al-Mustashfa: Jurnal Penelitian Hukum Ekonomi Syariah, 8(2), 251–260.

MUSTOFA, Z. (2024). Rekontruksi Pembiayaan Pemilikan Rumah Non Bank Oleh Developer Perumahan Syariah Berbasis Nilai Keadilan. Universitas Islam Sultan Agung Semarang.

NAJIB, A. (2020). Rekonstruksi Kewenangan Eksekusi Dan Pembatalan Putusan Arbitrase Syariah Dalam Perspektif Politik Hukum Indonesia. Program Studi Hukum Program Doktor Fakultas Hukum UII.

Norton, S. D. (2025). Financial innovation intra Muslim capital markets and inter global counterparts: implications of differences. Qualitative Research in Financial Markets, 17(1), 193–209.

Nugroho, E. R. (2021). Implementation Of Sharia-Compliance In Islamic Bank Product Innovations. Prophetic Law Review, 3(2). https://doi.org/10.20885/plr.vol3.iss2.art4

Nurjannah, M., Khudzaifah Dimyati, Setiaji, B., & B. (2020). Hukum dan Perbankan Syariah Dinamika, Konstruksi Paradigma Pembaharuan Hukum Islam di Indonesia. Muhammadiyah University Press. https://books.google.co.id/books?hl=id&lr=&id=RvXvEAAAQBAJ&oi=fnd&pg=PA24&dq=Secara+teoritis,+sistem+hukum+yang+mendukung+bank+syariah+adalah+sistem+yang+mengakomodasi+hukum+materiil+dan+prosedural+berbasis+syariah,+serta+memberikan+legitimasi+pada+prinsip-prinsip+fiqh+muamalah&ots=BaVgyWurek&sig=Clp4cE3BJM_4hCYKWTxoLozrQMc&redir_esc=y#v=onepage&q&f=false

Oralbaeva, Z., Dzhakisheva, O., Kurbanova, K., & Naukanova, A. (2020). Development opportunities of islamic finance in Kazakhstan: World experience and perspectives. E3S Web of Conferences, 159. https://doi.org/10.1051/e3sconf/202015906005

Permadi, A. (2023). Analisis Konstruktivis Institusionalisme Pada Proses Pendirian Bank Islam di Inggris. Sospol, 9(2), 206–219.

Peter Mahmud Marzuki. (2016). Penelitian Hukum. Kencana.

Pramesti, S. C., & Nisa, F. L. (2024). Mendukung Fintech Syariah: Upaya Pemerintah Indonesia dan Malaysia melalui Regulasi. Jurnal Ilmiah Ekonomi Dan Manajemen , 2(6), 520–528. https://ejurnal.kampusakademik.co.id/index.php/jiem/article/view/1533

Pusvisasari, L., Bisri, H., & Suntana, I. (2023). Analisis Filosofi dan Teori Hukum Ekonomi Syariah dalam Konteks Perbankan Syariah. Jurnal Ekonomi Utama, 2(3), 269–277.

Putri, M. W., Amin, M., & Baihaki, B. (2024). A Review of MUI Fatwa Number 4 of 2003 on the Standardization of Halal Fatwas Regarding the Use of Unusual Food Names in Palangka Raya. Al-Mustashfa: Jurnal Penelitian Hukum Ekonomi Syariah, 9(2), 157–171.

Putri, N. A. (2023). Urgensi Harmonisasi Undang-Undang Terkait Kewajiban Penyediaan Produk dan Jasa Pada Pariwisata Halal di Indonesia. Fakultas Syariah dan Hukum UIN Syarif Hidayatullah Jakarta.

Rana, S. S., Pingale, A., Gautam, D., Kumar, P., & Tilekar, S. J. (2025). A bibliometric exploration of religiosity and purchase intention. Multidisciplinary Reviews, 8(10). https://doi.org/10.31893/multirev.2025339

Reza, V. (2020). Pariwisata Halal Dalam Pengembangan Ekonomi Indonesia. Jurnal An-Nahl, 7(2), 106–112. https://doi.org/10.54576/annahl.v7i2.20

Ridawati, M. (2022). Kebijakan Pengembangan Produk Perbankan Syariah. TAFAQQUH, 7(2), 30–49.

Seng, Y. (2022). Towards Asean Bank Governance Coherence : Institute for Sustainable Industries and Livable Cities , Doctor of Business Administration.

Setyowati, R., Hussain, M. A., Markom, R., & Arif, M. I. A. M. (2023). The role of shariah authority in enhancing the Islamic financial system in Malaysia and Indonesia. Akademika, 93(1), 251–259.

Shahin, S. (2023). The Islamic Legal and Cultural Influences on Britain’s Shari’a Councils. December.

Sukardi, D., Nugraha, F. B., Ubaidillah, U., Fatakh, A., Leliya, L., & Arrizky, M. F. (2023). Solving Cyber Crime in Online Buying and Selling in Cirebon City in Review of ITE Law and Islamic Law. Al-Mustashfa: Jurnal Penelitian Hukum Ekonomi Syariah, 8(2), 237–250.

Supriyatni, R. (2020). Sharia Compliances Optimization in the Islamic Financial Industry Development. Systematic Reviews in Pharmacy, 11(8), 671–677. http://www.ojk.go.id/Files/box/roadmap-pbs_2015-2019.pdf.

Syamsuri, S., & Lutfiah, A. (2025). Analysis of Fraud in Transactions on Shopee: A Fiqh Muamalah Perspective Using the Fraud Triangle Theory. Al-Mustashfa: Jurnal Penelitian Hukum Ekonomi Syariah, 10(1), 1–19.

Triyanta, A., Hassan, R., Abdulmuslimov, M. R., & Hassan, R. (2024). The Connection Between Robust Legal Instruments And The Exceptional Performance Of The Islamic Banking Industry. Journal of Governance and Regulation/Volume, 13(2).

Usanti, T. P., & Shomad, A. (2022). Transaksi bank syariah. Bumi Aksara.

Yudhira, A. (2023). Dinamika Perkembangan Bank Syariah di Indonesia: Analisis Komprehensif. Jurnal Syiar-Syiar, 3(2), 34–45. https://doi.org/10.36490/syiar.v3i2.1074

Yulianti, D. I., Astuti, R. P., & Afton, M. D. R. (2025). Analisis Kebijakan dan Regulasi Perencanaan Keuangan Syariah di Indonesia: Tinjauan Hukum Tiga Lembaga Pengawasan: Perencanaan Keuangan Syariah. Jurnal Akademik Ekonomi Dan Manajemen, 2(2), 20–25.

Yusoff, N. Y., & Hassan, R. (2022). Corporate criminal liability in Islamic banks in Malaysia. ISRA International Journal of Islamic Finance, 14(3), 363–375. https://doi.org/10.1108/IJIF-04-2021-0067

Yusuf, H., Zubair, M. K., Aminah, S., Mahsyar, M., & Soi, A. B. (2025). The Principles of Islamic Business Ethics in the Viral Success of Donat Kampar Galesong: A Review of Islamic Economic Law. Al-Mustashfa: Jurnal Penelitian Hukum Ekonomi Syariah, 10(1), 40–56.

Yusuf, R., & Haryono, H. (2022). Analisis Kebijakan Makro Ekonomi Pemerintah Terhadap Peningkatan Market Share Bank Syariah di Indonesia. Ad-Deenar: Jurnal Ekonomi Dan Bisnis Islam, 6(01), 1. https://doi.org/10.30868/ad.v6i01.2285

DOI: 10.24235/jm.v10i1.20924